Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them Movie Review

Now that Harry Potter’s wand has been cinematically retired (at least until Warner Bros figures out how to eventually resuscitate him), it’s J.K. Rowling to the rescue with Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. This is the first entry in the wizardry world with a screenplay directly from the famed author who created it. This expands greatly on her 2001 novel (which is when Harry debuted onscreen) to create another franchise meant to draw youngsters into its spell, as well as Potter fans of all ages.

In order to achieve that goal, David Yates is back directing. He’s responsible for the last four features in the Potterverse. Our central character this time around is Newt Scamander (Eddie Redmayne), a magizoologist from London who comes to New York City circa 1926 with a briefcase full of creatures. It’s not clear immediately why he’s in the Big Apple, but his back story tells us of his time at a little school called Hogwarts where he was expelled and was tutored by a much younger Dumbledore.

Wizards need to be registered stateside and Newt finds himself generating the skepticism of Tina (Katherine Waterston), who works for MACUSA, the Magical Congress of the United States of America (obviously). She’s frustrated with her job, which is headed by its President (Carmen Ejogo) and enforced by Colin Farrell’s head of security. Newt and Tina team up to protect his various beasts and those who wish to destroy them. It’s not a two-person team as Newt befriends aspiring baker and World War I vet Jacob (Dan Fogler). Tina’s mind reading sister Queenie (Alison Sudol) is also involved and is the apple of Jacob’s eye. Before we continue with the rest of the review, let me declare that the subplot of Jacob and Queenie’s flirtation and budding romance was my favorite thing about the movie. Fogler serves as the general comic relief here anyway and does so quite wonderfully. Sudol shines in her first role. Their chemistry has genuine magic and if there was ever a case for a rom com spin-off of a hoped for multi-billion dollar franchise, this is it.

Moving on, that’s a small but very winning part of the two-hour plus running time. I wish I could say the chemistry between Newt and Tina was as impressive, but it’s not. Tina is a bit of a blank slate in this first installment and it certainly remains to be seen whether Redmayne’s Newt will come anywhere close to being as beloved as you know who. He’s got a long way to go. Not even Harry Potter could have sold doing a “mating dance” with a titillated CG rhino and neither can Newt. On the other hand, Beasts has its own version of a Star Wars-like cantina scene with Ron Perlman’s cool voicing of a nefarious creation and it’s a highlight.

There are other performances worthy of note, including Ezra Miller as an abused teen with mysterious powers and Samantha Morton as his wizard hating adopted mom doing the abuse. Our main villain Grindelwald is mostly just spoken of but not seen (kind of like Voldemort was for a bit), but we know he’ll play a bigger role as the series moves along.

Fantastic Beasts is heavy on effects (most of them eye-catching) and creating the visually arresting template for sequels. I didn’t think it reached a Sorcerer’s Stone level of quality as far as part 1’s, but Rowling is generally successful in making us curious about what comes next with this real and generated crop of characters.

*** (out of four)

4 thoughts on “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them Movie Review

  1. Uh, the fact that you highlight small, relatively plot-insignificant scenes like th “mating dance” scene rather than highlight Ezra Miller’s Credence more, aka, the character whom the plot pivots around, tells me you want this film to only be seen one way.

    This is very much a review that ignores the overall dark tone and heavy thematic presciency of the film in favor of selectively attending to insignificant lighthearted moments in order to twistedly justify calling this film “light” or “insubstantial.”

    And again, Grindelwald played a huge role in this film and you don’t seem to have caught that at all. It’s like the central plot of him, disguised as someone else, attacking New York with an Obscurus while scapegoating Newt was entirely lost on you. Which is concerning, considering how, if you ignore that…you really have no film.

    You highlight a comic relief character that has no active role in the plot as your favorite thing about the film…Fantastic.

    This is an embarrassing, uneven, uninformed, ridiculously unthorough review.

    1. Appreciate your thoughts, but I go by what personally stuck out for me in any review. The two characters highlighted were the two that grabbed my attention the most. I do say in the review that it’s a small but winning part of the runtime. Certainly realize that Grindelwald character will grow in significance in later installments. Would disagree that Kowalski character has no significance as they made his presence a major point in the plot and even ended the film with his meeting Queenie again for the first time.

      1. Oh my god, Jacob had no active role in the plot. He was passive throughout the entire second act to everyone else, served as a victim to only exposition, and was absent for nearly the entire third act, playing no role whatsoever in the rising action and the climax. None. He was literally there just to be a funny guy.

        And as I say in my review, Percival Graves, AKA GRINDELWALD, plays a huge role in the film. The plot pivots around his actions in attacking New York City. If you can’t understand this simple fact then you shouldn’t be reviewing the film.

      2. I didn’t discuss some of the plot details in my review because it would be completely spoiling the entire film. But thanks for the feedback. I get it. You don’t like my review. Happy New Year!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.