Oscar Predictions: The Piano Lesson

The Piano Lesson is the third adaptation of an August Wilson play in the past decade seeking Oscar glory. This is a Washington family affair with siblings Malcolm directing and John David headlining. Their father Denzel is a producer. Piano has played at Telluride (with Toronto next) before its limited November 8th theatrical release and November 22nd Netflix premiere. Cast members include Samuel L. Jackson, Ray Fisher, Michael Potts, Erykah Badu, Corey Hawkins, and Danielle Deadwyler.

Early reviews are decent with some gripes about its stagey nature. Before we get to its awards chances, let’s take a look at how fellow Wilson adaptations Fences in 2016 and Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom in 2020 performed. Fences, directed by Denzel, landed four nominations: Picture, Denzel in Actor, Viola Davis in Supporting Actress for which she won, and Adapted Screenplay. Ma Rainey managed five mentions for Actor (Chadwick Boseman), Actress (Viola Davis), Costume Design (where it took gold), Makeup & Hairstyling (another victory), and Production Design.

With that track record, Piano has rightfully been viewed as a serious contender in numerous races. This weekend’s buzz solidifies some of that chatter while muddying other possibilities. Danielle Deadwyler appears to be the cast’s standout. It is not yet known if Netflix will campaign for her in lead or supporting though the latter seems more likely. If they do, a nod seems close to assured and that would come two years after she was snubbed in Actress for Till.

For weeks, I’ve had Samuel L. Jackson listed in 1st place in Supporting Actor. Despite a career with a lengthy list of highlights, his sole nom came 30 years ago for Pulp Fiction. Now I’m not even sure he makes the cut as his costar Ray Fisher is getting equally strong ink. Jackson could make the final quintet. However, I suspect I’ll at least drop him from the top slot. John David Washington faces longer odds in lead Actor, but let’s see how crowded that competition becomes.

Best Picture is a question mark. I think it could make it in though it would be at the bottom of the 10 hopefuls and may miss altogether. Down the line techs like Costume Design, Makeup & Hairstyling, and Production Design (the ones Rainey received) could happen with Adapted Screenplay in the mix. One must wonder if Netflix decides to push Emilia Pérez as their #1 option and the answer is probably yes. My Oscar Prediction posts will continue…

Oscar Predictions: Rustin

As the gay activist instrumental in organizing Martin Luther King Jr.’s March on Washington, Colman Domingo has been seen as a serious Best Actor possibility since Rustin was announced. The biopic has premiered in Telluride prior to its November 3rd limited theatrical release and November 17th Netflix streaming start. George C. Wolfe, in his follow-up to Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom, directs with a supporting cast including Chris Rock, Glynn Turman, Ami Ameen, CCH Pounder, Michael Potts, Jeffrey Wright, and Audra McDonald.

Festival reviews indicate Domingo should find himself among the lead Actor quintet and that’s even with the already considerable competition (it’s going to be tricky to figure out who gets snubbed). The pic itself sits at 100% on Rotten Tomatoes.

It will be interesting to see Netflix’s campaign. They’re sure to go all in on Bradley Cooper’s Maestro and their BP blitz for Rustin could be more muted. There’s certainly the chance that Domingo represents its only nod (though Lenny Kravitz has a track called “Road to Freedom” that could make it). If the love extends to supporting, perhaps Turman contends. I’m skeptical about that. As for Domingo, it sure seems like the voters will go his way for a spot. My Oscar Prediction posts will continue…